You're Not Going to School. You're Taking Out a Business Loan.


You're Not Going to School. You're Taking Out a Business Loan.

On tuition, opportunity cost, and why the most expensive part of your degree never shows up on the bill.


If your career requires college, you are not just "going off to school."

You are walking into a bank and asking for a business loan. You are just doing it in a hoodie instead of a blazer.

That may sound cold. Maybe even a little offensive. We like to talk about college in softer language. Growth. Discovery. Opportunity. Transformation. Finding yourself. Becoming who you were meant to be.

And all of that can be true.

But if the job you want requires a credential — associate degree, bachelor's, DVM, MD, JD, nursing, engineering, accounting — then school is not just an experience. It is the startup phase of your career business. Your degree is the operating license. Your tuition is the startup cost. Your lost wages are the revenue you gave up while building the asset. Your future income is the return you are hoping that asset eventually produces.

That does not mean college is bad. It does not mean every decision should live inside a spreadsheet. It does not mean calling, purpose, service, and professional identity do not matter.

It means the decision deserves more thought than, "Well, I guess this is the next step."


The Staircase Story We Were All Sold

For decades, most of us were handed the same narrative: work hard, get good grades, go to college, maybe go to grad school, and success will somehow sort itself out on the back end.

It was a comforting story. It gave parents something to say at graduation parties and gave students a direction when adulthood was standing in the driveway revving its engine.

But the staircase story has a problem. It usually skips the math. And the math matters.

Education still pays. Workers with higher credentials generally have higher earnings and lower unemployment — the broad pattern is real. But "education pays on average" is not the same as "every degree at every price from every school pays equally for every person." That is where people get themselves in trouble.

Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York has estimated the annual return on a college degree in the low double digits, often somewhere around 9 to 15 percent depending on assumptions — a strong number by investment standards. But that is an average. Returns vary wildly by major, by school, and by what you actually do with the credential afterward. "College" is not one monolithic bet. It is a portfolio of small businesses — some cash cows, some break-even, some bleeding money quietly in the back room.


The Bill Nobody Shows You

Universities are required to post their sticker prices. You can click around a website, see tuition and fees, and feel like you are making an informed decision.

The math that matters most usually lives off the brochure.

Analysts who try to tally the total cost of a four-year degree — direct costs plus opportunity cost — often land in a wide band that runs roughly from the mid–$100,000s to well over $250,000, depending on the type of school, assumptions about living expenses, and how you value the wages you gave up while you were in class. For a typical in‑state student at a public university, a reasonable illustrative scenario might look like this over four years:

  • Tens of thousands of dollars in direct educational costs (tuition, fees, and books).
  • Well into the five figures — and often six — in foregone wages, if you could otherwise have been working full-time.

In many realistic scenarios, the opportunity cost rivals or exceeds the direct tuition bill, especially if the alternative is full‑time work at a modest but steady wage.

That opportunity cost is the sneaky line item nobody mentions: The salary you could have earned working full-time. The promotions you did not qualify for yet. The retirement contributions that never got made. The experience you were not stacking while your peers were.

Stretch that to six, seven, or eight years for a professional degree, and the invisible cost starts to rival — or exceed — the debt itself.

None of this means you should not go. It means when you sign up for a degree, you are not just buying classes and a campus. You are also buying "years I cannot get back," and those years carry a price tag whether they show up on a billing statement or not.


Three Versions of Required School

The two-year associate degree. Think allied health, technical trades, etc. Shorter time out of the workforce, lower tuition, faster path to a real paycheck. Many of these programs have a clear, direct line between training and employment. They can be excellent investments — and they are frequently underestimated.

The four-year bachelor’s degree. Much more variable. Engineering, accounting, computer science, and nursing tend to have direct lines to strong employment. The Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity analyzed tens of thousands of degree programs and found that bachelor’s degrees offer a median lifetime financial return on the order of roughly $150,000–$160,000 — but that median hides the fact that around one in four bachelor’s programs produce a negative return on investment once opportunity cost is factored in. Their work also suggests that a large minority — approaching half — of master’s programs leave students financially worse off on paper compared with stopping at a bachelor’s degree. That is not an argument against graduate school. It is an argument for knowing which bucket your program falls into before you sign.

The professional degree. Medicine, veterinary medicine, dentistry, law, pharmacy, and other licensed professions. High tuition, long training, significant opportunity cost, and a side of six‑figure educational debt for many graduates. Across these programs, it is common to see average educational debt land well into the low‑ to mid‑six‑figure range for students who borrow, with a sizable fraction carrying even higher balances. Debt‑to‑income ratios that hover around or above 1.0 are often framed as “manageable” within these professions, but the underlying trend is similar in many fields: training costs and debt burdens have risen faster than compensation, and a non‑trivial share of new professionals are starting their careers with ratios that would make any banker raise an eyebrow.

That is not doom. That is data. And data is what you need before you sign a loan.


Walking Into the Bank

Imagine you actually had to sit across from a loan officer and pitch your degree as a small business.

They would not be impressed if your business plan sounded like, "Everyone says this is a good idea." They would want answers to the same four questions every banker asks.

How much do you really need?

Not the sticker price — the real all‑in number. Tuition, fees, housing, books, living expenses, and the income you are walking away from to be there. For a typical four‑year degree at a state school, many reasonable estimates put the total investment (including opportunity cost) somewhere between roughly $150,000 and $250,000 or more, depending on methodology and assumptions. We are not talking about pocket change. If you would hesitate to say, "Yes, I would like a $150,000 business loan, please," then it is worth at least pausing before signing for the same number dressed up as a "financial aid package."

What exactly are you buying?

In banker language: what is your business model? In school language: what specific jobs does this degree qualify you for? What is a realistic starting salary in your region — not the heroic outlier, not the person on social media who claims to earn $400,000 while working six hours a week from a lake house with suspiciously perfect lighting. A real starting salary. Are there actual openings, or are you training for a job that does not exist where you plan to live?

A two‑year degree that reliably feeds into an in‑demand, licensure‑based role is a fundamentally different business than a generic four‑year degree that leaves you shrugging when someone asks what you can do now. Both are "college." But one has a clear revenue stream and the other is closer to an expensive personality test.

How and when does it pay back?

You do not need a complicated model. You need two honest stories.

Scenario A: No school. You take the best job you can get right now and estimate what that income looks like over the next ten years.

Scenario B: School. You account for lower or no earnings during the program, then plug in a realistic starting salary and modest growth afterward. Add up tuition, living expenses, and the wages you did not earn while in class. Then ask: how many years of extra income, compared to Scenario A, does it take to break even?

If you cannot sketch a plausible path to break even within a reasonable window after graduation, the business case is shaky. Not necessarily wrong — but shaky. And for some careers, the honest answer is: "This will not pay itself back quickly. I am choosing it anyway because the work matters that much to me." That is not a failure of math. That is clarity — and clarity is something you can build a plan around.

What if things go sideways?

No bank assumes every projection hits. Neither should you.

What if you need an extra year to finish? What if the job market is soft when you graduate? What if you discover the highest‑paying roles in your field are the ones you would least enjoy?

Studies on student debt consistently show that higher loan balances influence early‑career choices: graduates with more debt are more likely to prioritize higher pay quickly and less likely to take lower‑paying roles that might better match their interests or long‑term goals. That is not a reason to avoid debt at all costs. It is a reason to ask whether your plan survives the first time reality walks in holding a wrench.


But What If It Is a Calling?

Here is where someone always pushes back. What about medicine? Veterinary medicine? Teaching? Law? We have to go to school for that. The credential is not optional.

Exactly right. Please do not choose your surgeon because he seems scrappy. Do not pick your pilot because she has always loved clouds. Do not hand your animal to someone who found a workaround on the internet. Some work requires serious preparation, and it should. The credential exists for a reason.

But that is precisely why the conversation needs to be more honest — not less. Because the people who go into medicine or law or veterinary medicine are not making a casual bet. They are making one of the largest financial commitments of their lives, often before they have made a car payment or signed a lease, and frequently with a level of self-awareness about the math that is somewhere between "vague" and "none."

The business-loan framework is not here to talk anyone out of a calling. It is here so people can walk into that calling with their eyes open. There is a meaningful difference between telling yourself "this degree is a great financial investment" and telling yourself "this is a costly decision I am making on purpose because the work matters that much to me." The second version is honest. And honest people make better decisions — they choose the in-state school over the prestigious name they cannot recoup, they live modestly in the early years and attack the debt before it starts making decisions for them, they plan ahead for the ways leadership or specialization or geography might bend the math in their favor later.

The people I have watched struggle most in this profession are not the ones who chose a hard path. They are the ones who chose it without looking at where the path actually went.


The Difference Between Owners and Passengers

There is a version of this story where a young person walks into enrollment because it is what everyone does after undergrad, signs the paperwork because the alternative feels vague and frightening, and spends the next decade wondering why the career they worked so hard for feels like a financial trap.

That person is a passenger.

An owner walks into the same building, sits down with the same paperwork, and asks a different set of questions. Not "what sounds impressive" but "what does this qualify me to do." Not "I'll figure out the money later" but "what are the actual terms of this loan I am about to take on my time, my income, and the next decade of my life." Not "everyone says it'll work out" but "what happens if it doesn't work out exactly as planned — and can I survive that?"

The credential may be required. The thoughtfulness is not. That part is entirely voluntary, and most people skip it.

The ones who do not skip it — who walk in knowing what they are signing, why they are signing it, and what they plan to do when the bill comes due — those are the ones who tend to come out the other side with something that looks less like regret and more like a career they actually chose.


Before You Sign

If you are heading into a program — any program — or watching someone you care about make this decision, there is really only one question that matters before the ink hits the page:

If I had to walk into a bank and justify this degree as a business loan — tuition, living costs, and the years I cannot get back all on the table — what would I say?

You do not need a perfect answer. You do not need a spreadsheet or a ten-year projection or a financial advisor sitting next to you. You just need something better than a shrug.

Because you are not going off to school. You are making one of the largest investments of your life. The least it deserves is a real pitch.



References

  1. Physician on FIRE. How Much Student Debt Does the Average Doctor Owe? October 2025. https://www.physicianonfire.com/medical-school-debt-repayment-guide/
  2. CNBC / Federal Reserve Bank of New York. College is worth the money for most graduates, new Fed research finds. April 18, 2025. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/04/18/median-return-on-investment-for-a-college-degree.html
  3. Cooper, Preston. Does College Pay Off? A Comprehensive Return on Investment Analysis. Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity (FREOPP). January 2026. https://freopp.org/whitepapers/does-college-pay-off-a-comprehensive-return-on-investment-analysis/
  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Education Pays, 2024. Career Outlook, 2025.
  5. Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce. Ranking 4,500 Colleges by ROI. 2025. https://cew.georgetown.edu/cew-reports/roi2025/